# Kegging CO2 Use Estimations and Calculations

Have you ever wondered how much CO2 it takes to pressurize a keg or carbonate your beer?  Read on.

Here is my 35 lb Digital Scale showing the total weight in grams of a 5 gallon ball lock keg that contains 10 PSI of CO2.  The total weight comes out to 4,320 grams

This photo shows the weight of that same keg with 30 PSI of CO2.  That means that 20 PSI of CO2, in a 5 gallon ball lock, weighs about 50 grams (1.76 ounces).

That’s 1/2 gram per gallon per PSI.  (.5 grams of CO2 x 5 gallons x 20 PSI = 50 grams)

The pictured 30 PSI test was the most straightforward that I completed, but in all, I weighed 9 different pressure changes using two different CO2 gauges and two different scales.  The average of those 9 tests was very close to the 30 PSI test coming in an adjusted 52.5 grams for 20 PSI of CO2.  Most tests were right in line with the .5 gram/PSI/Gallon rule of thumb, with one anomaly.

It’s worth noting a couple additional things.  First a 5 gallon keg isn’t exactly 5 gallons.  I measured this one at 5 gallons + 1.5 Quarts.  Second, my scales don’t have single gram resolution at this this weight.  The 35 lb Digital Scale has a 5 gram resolution at anything over 1 kg.

What about atmospheric pressure?  The pressure we measure with our CO2 gauges is relative.  10 PSI is really 10 PSI above atmospheric pressure (14.7 PSI at sea level).  That means a serving pressure of 10 PSI equates to an absolute pressure of 24.7 PSI.  My estimate of 25 grams per 10 PSI in a 5 gallon keg is accurate if you’re just pressurizing a keg starting at atmospheric pressure (you’d end up with about 40% CO2 combined with about 60% air).  If you want to purge the keg to begin with you need to offset the the 14.7 PSI of atmosphere.  A completely purged keg would require 61.75 grams of CO2 (.5 x 24.7 x 5).  Of course, this is difficult to do perfectly because as you purge the keg CO2 is going to mix with air.  To accomplish this you would need to somehow pull a vacuum on the keg (which it isn’t designed for) and then flood the keg with 61.75 grams of CO2.  CO2 is heavier than air, so your best bet to efficiently purge is to do it slowly from the bottom of the keg up.  This will drive the air out and minimize mixture.  Of course this ends up being a lot easier and a lot less CO2 with amount of head space we typically have.  You flood that small area with CO2 and purge a few times and you end up with a high concentration of CO2.

Carbonated Beer Estimations.  We measure carbonation in number of volumes.  What are the volumes we’re talking about?  Volumes of atmosphere.  Here’s a formula to estimate this using my findings…

Weight of CO2 Used for Carbonation = Volumes of Carbonation x 14.7 x 1/2 x Volume of Beer

Let’s assume 2.5 volumes and 5 gallons of beer…

2.5 x 14.7 x .5 x 5 = 91.875 grams (3.24 ounces)

That’s 3.24 ounces (weight) of CO2.  That means one lb of CO2 should carbonate 4.93 (5 gallon) kegs of beer.

Serving Estimations.  The CO2 Used for serving would just need to take into account serving pressure, atmospheric pressure and keg size…

Weight of CO2 Used for Serving = (Serving Pressure + Atmospheric Pressure) x 1/2 x Keg Volume

This assumes a balanced system where you would use the same pressure to store, carbonate and dispense.

Let’s assume 10 PSI and a 5 gallon keg…

(10 + 14.7) x 1/2 x 5 = 61.75 grams (2.18 ounces)

CO2 Use in Estimated Kegs per lb.  Continuing with our example… we would use 153.625 (91.875 + 61.75) grams (5.41 Ounces) of CO2 to carbonate and dispense.

That’s 2.96 kegs per lb of CO2 or 14.8 kegs per 5 lb tank.  Keep reading.

Practically speaking, these numbers do not match up with what you can realistically expect to get out of a CO2 tank.  Possible reasons: Variances in temperature, leaks, micro leaks, purging losses, under-filled tanks, variances in atmospheric pressure (14.7 = sea level) and/or higher carbonation levels.  Realistically, I would figure on 1 to 2  kegs per lb of CO2.  At 2 kegs per lb, you’re getting approximately 66% CO2 efficiency.

Take Aways:

• Rule of thumb for estimating weigh to CO2 in a keg – 1/2 gram per gallon per PSI
• Purging a 5 gallon keg will take at least 36.75 grams of CO2 (14.7 x .5 x 5).  Practically speaking it will take more.
• Weight of CO2 Used to Carbonate = Volumes of Carbonation x 14.7 x .5 x Volume of Beer
• Weight of CO2 Used for Dispensing = (Serving PSI + 14.7) x .5 x Keg Volume in Gallons

Use the comments of this post to add to the discussion and correct me where necessary.  I may have some misconceptions or misunderstandings about how this works.  I will incorporate your feedback into this post as needed.

Credits: Thanks to Redditor speedplayfrog for your help with this post, including help clarifying the concept of relative vs absolute pressure and for correcting my original serving estimation calculation.

Pinned: Used Barrels · CO2 Manifold · New:Tower of Power · \$7:Bazooka Screen

Talk Like a Pirate Sale: 13% Off at Adventures in Homebrewing

Tips and Gear for Your Kegerator:

Recent Draft Finds:

# Q & A with Dr Chris White – 27 Questions Answered!

White Labs recently announced new PurePitch yeast packaging for homebrewers.  The new packaging goes hand in hand with a new propagation method White Labs is calling the Flexcell Process.

White Labs Description of Flexcell:
Instead of traditional stainless steel fermenters, the patent-pending FlexCell process allows White Labs to propagate yeast with no exposure to the environment all the way to packaging, ensuring its quality and purity.

• Since the yeast is grown and packaged in the same material the new PurePitch packaging is actually a part of the fermentor, and its contents have never been exposed to the environment.
• PurePitch Packaging is breathable and allows CO2 to escape. Reduced chance of gas build-up.
• This packaging will maintain the yeast in a more stress-free state.

Look for new PurePitch Packaging on Homebrew Finds – connect with HBF – when it’s released sometime this fall.

As part of the release of PurePitch Packaging, Dr Chris White PhD, President and CEO of White Labs wanted to hear directly from Homebrew Finds Readers.  We asked you for your questions about the new packaging and yeast and fermentation in general back in July.  Questions and answers follow.

Thanks to all who submitted questions and thank you to Dr Chris White!

Look for new PurePitch Packaging on Homebrew Finds when it’s released sometime this fall.

Q 1. When White Labs propagates yeast, what measures are taken to ensure that no mutations take hold?

A.  Our attention for looking for mutations hasn’t changed with the new technology. We built a big back end to our yeast production at the beginning. We have a specialized team that works with freezes – check for mutations, by specialized plating, genetic analysis and performance. We are constantly checking for mutations. In addition we minimize time we have yeast on plates and our propagation is limited to 17 days. These tools and personal that separates us from being a yeast propagator and we maintain these yeast in there integrity is one of our missions.

Q 2.  Gluten-free brewers are mostly restricted to dry yeast strains, because liquid yeasts are shipped in a medium that contains gluten. Is the PurePitch packaging gluten free, or is it still the same as before?

A.  The yeast within the PurePitch packaging is the same as before. We do, however, carry a product called Clarity Ferm, which can help reduce gluten to under 10 ppm in beer.

Q 3.  What are the ideal mash parameters, yeast strains, and fermentation temperatures to accentuate each of the following ester/phenol characters in a hefeweizen: clove, banana, and bubble gum?

A.  Hef yeast strains that we have are selected to maximize these characteristics. Anything that encourages yeast growth will increase those 3 flavors. Pitching less and higher fermentation temperature that encourage growth are 2 examples. Aerating less will also encourage growth – another parameter that can increase esters.

Q 4.  What yeast or blend of yeasts would you recommend to try and recreate keeping at home?

A.  If traditional methods are followed for keeping our WLP775 WL cider yeast is the best choice.

Q 5.  Is it possible to dry yeast at home for storage and later use?

A.  You will get very low viability dry yeast at home, so it’s not recommended. If you did, you would need to check the viability after rehydrating.

Q 6.  Would it be possible to make a Servomyces substitute at home? If so, could you suggest how it could be done?

A.  No, it is not, as it’s a patented process.

Q 7.  The new packaging says it’s breathable so it allows co2 to escape. Even though it’s breathable- I would think if the package is sealed the yeast would be under considerable pressure during reproduction and may have a negative effect on yeast health during its growth. Is that not really a factor or is it accounted for somehow?

A.  During the propagation, the vessel is constructed with blow-off valves to allow all of the pressure to escape while the culture is being oxygenated and growing.

Q 8.  Is the new packaging permeable to oxygen? If so does that negatively affect the shelf life of the product?

A.  We are still conducting trials to test the shelf life, but initial trials indicate the
shelf life may even be prolonged.

Q 9.  As temperature fluctuates there is the chance the package will also take in outside air. Especially for people who get yeast delivered in warm months. The yeast temperature fluctuate from cold to warm and back to cold. Have you done tests to see how much outside air gets in and it’s effect on the yeast?

A.  The film technology is only allowing gas pressure to escape, but not the other way (like a one-way check valve)

Q 10.  You indicate the packaging material is recyclable. What material is it made of as some states have restrictions?

A.  #2 plastic

Q 11.  Will the new packaging have more strain specific information regarding optimum conditions?

A.  Yes, we’ve broken the yeast strains into categories with more specific strain-related recommendations, including Brett/Bacteria.  We grouped them into 6 different strain styles. Within the 6, we have specific information for example, like Lagers. The 6 strain types are differentiated by color on the package. Furthermore we are actively pertaining more information on our strains via our tasting room and brewery to add more information to our yeast descriptions that are found online and printed material.

Q 12.  How is a uniform cell count, or a known cell count, maintained in each unit when the culture is packaged using this new packaging technology?

A.  We’re using automated cell counting technology to validate the consistency of the culture prior to final packaging.

Q 13.  Was there an issue with the old packaging that prompted for the redesign (I understand the improved packaging for retailers to take up significantly less shelf space, but was it a yeast reason or was this a response to increases in vial costs or actual issues with the old storage methods?) Will this keep yeast more viable for longer periods of time?

A.  This was prompted to reduce the amount of transfers yeast makes to be propagated, concentrated, tested and packaged. From our first thoughts of this process, it was driven by the desire to make better yeast. We have always liked the vial, but we didn’t want that to cloud our desire to make better yeast. By utilizing this new technology, we can offer yeast that has never been exposed to the environment. We have seen better viability over time as well, which is due to release of CO2 and from less time and handling to fill packages.

Q 14.  You sell ~100 billion cells per package. These packages include instructions indicating they are directly pitchable into 5 gallons of wort up to ~1.060. However, every brewer of any experience seems to accept as gospel that yeast starters are required for nearly any batch – Jamil Z.’s online calculator claims that 100 billion cells are barely enough for 5 gallons at 1.034, for example. Why, then, has White Labs not marketed a package of 200 or 250 billion cells for homebrew use? This would allow homebrewers to brew beers in the meat of the homebrewing space – say 1.050 – 1.075 – without the trouble of making starters for every batch.

A.  We are actually increasing the number of cells per package to 2.5 to 3 billion cells per ml. And laboratory grown yeast won’t necessarily follow the pitching rate guidelines since they are very healthy. The pitching rate recommendations traditionally refer to re-pitched yeast. Also, you are not getting a lot of growth from a starter unless it is an adequate size.

Q 15.  The number of cells in each pack strains the minimal requirements for a 5 gallon session strength beer (ie. 250,000 cells/ml/P). And that’s given 100% viability, which is almost never likely due to unavoidable transportation and long term storage issues at LHBS. With the new packages will there be options for larger volumes, (e.g. 200e9 cells) to help address these? Minimal costs additions, offset by new pack savings, would definitely drive market share higher.

A.  See answer to #14. With yeast it is similar to beer pricing, if you buy 1 liter of beer it is usually only slightly less than the price of 2 pints, because you have to make twice as much on the manufacturing side.  But we are open to different sizes in the future, it just won’t be as ‘less
expensive’ as people might think. Please keep the feedback on sizes coming to White Labs.

Q 16.  What temperature should I make a yeast starter at? Room temp, warmer or cooler?

A.  Room temperature or warmer (close to 75F or 24C)

Q 17.  How long should I let a yeast starter run on a stir plate? Is there a recommended duration, or some visual indication that the colony is ready?

A.  24-48 hrs. The only visual confirmation you can get would be to count the yeast and examine them under the microscope.

Q 18.  Should I drain the starter wort first? Should I chill the starter to help it settle before doing so?

A.  It is mostly personal preference but if you are decanting the starter wort you should let it settle and chilling it will accelerate that.

Q 19.  What temperature should I pitch at? At target fermentation temperature, or some measure below?

A.  We recommend pitching at 70, then bringing the temp down to fermentation temperature when fermentation begins.

Q 20.  Can I over do it with oxygen in the wort when I pitch my yeast? I have been doing some experiments with extending the time that I run O2 on my wort when I pitch. I have a commercial size O2 tank & regulator and .5 micron stone that I use to oxygenate my 10 gal all grain batches. I noticed that increasing my O2 run improved the start on my ferment and produced better all around results. So, I started extending the time that I ran my o2, just to see what would happen. I expected to see a point where my results started to fall off. This did not seem to happen. I continued to extend my oxygenation up to about 35 minutes at about 1 liter per minute. I do not have the equipment to do cell counts and so my results are fairly subjective, but, it seems to me that at least up to 15 minutes I observed improvements in fermentation. Can I hurt the cells with a 15 minute O2 run and at what point am I just wasting my time. Using the large o2 cylinder, the cost is very minimal and I am not concerned with it. My primary interest is producing better beer. What will make my yeast perform best?

A.  In homebrew set ups, it is very hard to over oxygenate. Once saturation is reached, excess oxygen will not go into solution. So at that point extra oxygen will be wasted. In commercial operations, they sometimes get over oxygenation because they are oxygenating in line, which can create over pressure which allows more oxygen to dissolve into solution.

Q 21.  In your book you mention how important adding oxygen to wort for proper fermentation. Is there a specific amount to add correlated to original gravity? Such as X liters for 5 gallons of 1.040 and Y more for every increase of 5 points?

A.  It is not about flow rate of oxygen, that will be different for every set up and every beer. What you want is 8 to 10 ppm of dissolved oxygen in the wort. The difficult part about knowing that is most people do not have the equipment to measure dissolved oxygen.

Q 22.  Any brewer who’s tasted their wort knows it tastes much more bitter than the beer it is eventually turned into by yeast. To what extent is the pre- and post-fermentation IBU difference dependent on yeast strain? If it does vary by yeast strain, do you think this would be a useful value to include in each yeast’s spec sheet?

A.  Yes, it is affected by different yeast strains. We have been studying this in our brewery/tasting room, and are working on a publication to make this information available to everyone.

Q 23.  Will White Labs be able to produce consistent yeast blends with this new method of packaging?

A.  Yes

Q 24.  Will the work with Yeast Bay migrate over to the new packaging?

A.  Yes

Q 25.  Will the new method of packaging effect cell counts of Bret and Lacto?

A.  No, the cell counts will remain the same

Q 26.  Is it possible to clean up a batch of yeast using water purification drops (the kind used for camping)? What are the chances of killing the yeast or reducing its abilities?

A.  No, the yeast would be killed.

Q 27.  When making high-gravity beer can I viably use distiller’s yeast in the secondary fermentation chamber after the primary yeast has done most of the work to lower the FG a little further?

A.  You can always try it but not all distiller’s yeast are considered high gravity yeast

Related:

Pinned: Used Barrels · CO2 Manifold · New:Tower of Power · \$7:Bazooka Screen

Talk Like a Pirate Sale: 13% Off at Adventures in Homebrewing

Recent Great Deals:

# Balancing your Draft System + Three Things I learned about Draft Dispensing at NHC

I had the pleasure of attending the National Homebrewer’s Conference held in Grand Rapids, Michigan this past week.  If you didn’t have the chance to go, or even if you did, the AHA will be providing recordings of every seminar held at this year’s NHC.  In fact you can pick up recordings going back to 2012′s conference.  This is a member’s only benefit.  If you’re not a member of the AHA, I think you should consider joining.  Access to conference materials is only one of many benefits.  Join nowCheck out the benefits.

One of the sessions I attended was Tom Schmidlin’s “Draft System Design and Maintenance”.  Having built several kegerators over the years, clarification – several iterations of the same kegerator, I feel like a know a fair bit about putting together a system.  Many things were re-affirmations of lessons I’ve learned.  I did pick up a few new tips.  Thank you to Tom Schmidlin for putting on this great presentation!

Note that all of these ideas are not exactly notes from Tom’s presentation.  I specifically note items that I recall picking up from him.  All three “What I learned about Draft Dispensing at NHC” are from Tom’s presentation.

Temperature and Pressure:
The carbonation level of your beer is a function of your CO2 PSI and your kegerator temperature.  The colder your kegerator, the more CO2 your beer will absorb.  You need to decide two things: How cold do I want my beer to be and what carbonation level do I want to serve it at.

1.  Carbonation Level.  Typically expressed in volumes of dissolved CO2.  Check out the BJCP’s style guidelines for a starting point.  The guidelines give general terms like low, moderately low, high, very high, etc.  Other more specific charts and tools are also available.  Most recipe formulation tools have guidelines or tools on the subject including BeerSmith and Brewer’s Friend.  Tasty Brew’s Carbonation Calculator also has built in guidelines.

2.  Temperature.  Tom said that most bars serve between 34 and 38 deg F.  Of course, this is a personal preference.

After you have determined carbonation level and temperature you’d like you can use a carbonation chart or calculator to determine what pressure you need to store your beer at.

Click To Enlarge.  This graphic is found all around the web.  I believe that credit goes to the great John Palmer of How to Brew fame.

Example:  If you’d like your beer to be 38 degrees and you want 2.4 volumes of CO2, you would find 38 degrees on the far left hand column and then follow it over to the right until you find something similar to 2.4.  After you have located that, follow that column up and you’ll find your required storage and serving PSI.  In this case, 10 PSI.

Serving Beers with Multiple Carbonation Levels

If you want to serve beers at different pressures you’ll need multiple regulators…

This is a secondary regulator meaning that it has no high pressure gauge or connection.  This hooks on to your existing primary regulator and allows you to serve up to four additional pressures.  In combination with your primary regulator you can actually serve up to 5 pressures.  Set the primary to your highest desired pressure level, put in a T or manifold on the primary outlet and feed the secondary from there.  Check it out – Here

This is the double bodied regulator that I currently use.  It allows me to serve at two carbonation levels.  I feed a manifold off one regulator with what I’ll call my standard or house carbonation level – and have a single line going off the other regulator for beers that I want to serve at a different carbonation level or for force carbing a keg at a higher pressure.  Check it out – Here

If you simply want to split one of your pressures for use in multiple kegs, a manifold will do the trick.  These give you multiple tubing runs, have integrated check valves to prevent cross contamination and have valves to control each link.  The list of things that grow with you in homebrewing is… short.  You can’t add on two gallons to your brew kettle.  This expandable manifold system from More Beer is one thing that will actually grow with you.  Check it out – Here

Now that you have your beer at your preferred temperature and carbonation level you need to be able to dispense it at the proper speed and without excessive foam.  A common goal is 1 gallon per minute or about 2 ounces per second.  That’s accomplished by balancing your system.  Essentially, you want to offset most of the pressure (all but about 1 PSI) that is required to store and carbonate your beer with resistance in your system.  Everything on the liquid side of your system counts toward this resistance.

Some resistance estimations…

Tubing – credit goes to the Draught Quality Manual for these figures:

• Vinyl 3/16” ID 3.00 lbs/ft
• Vinyl 1/4” ID 0.85 lbs/ft
• Vinyl 5/16” ID 0.40 lbs/ft
• Vinyl 3/8” ID 0.20 lbs/ft
• Vinyl 1/2” ID 0.025 lbs/ft
• Barrier 1/4” ID 0.30 lbs/
• Barrier 5/16” ID 0.10 lbs/ft
• Barrier 3/8” ID 0.06 lbs/ft
• Stainless 1/4” OD 1.20 lbs/ft
• Stainless 5/16” OD 0.30 lbs/ft
• Stainless 3/8” OD 0.12 lbs/ft

Note:  Most Homebrewers that I know use either 1/4″ or 3/16″ ID Vinyl with the majority of those using 3/16″ ID Vinyl.  Lower resistance options are typically used by commercial establishments that are usually trying to reduce resistance.

Note: More Beer has recently EJ Beverage’s Line of PVC Free, Antibacterial, Low Permeability Tubing.  Each of those options include estimated lbs of restriction per foot.  Check that tubing line out – Here

Other:

• Standard Faucet and Shank – Tom estimates 5 lbs for these items
• Picnic or Cobra Faucet – .5 lbs
• Rise in elevation – .5lbs/ft of rise, measured from the center of the keg

Example: Continuing our previous example, we had our pressure set to 10 PSI.  Everything on the liquid side of the system counts toward the system’s resistance.  Let’s say you’re using a picnic tap and 3/16″ ID Tubing.

Picnic Tap = .5 lbs

Estimated Rise from Center of Keg = 2 ft = 1 lb

Total = 1.5 lbs of resistance

That leaves us 7.5 lbs that we need to use up.  We’re using 3/16″ ID Tubing (3 lbs/ft).  We’ll need a total of 2.5 ft of tubing to offset the required pressure.

The total system looks like this…

Picnic Tap = .5 lbs
Estimated Rise from Center of Keg = 2 ft = 1 lb
2.5 ft of 3/16″ ID Tubing = 7.5 lbs

Total = 9 lbs of resistance

Remaining = 1 PSI to serve beer

But wait… you should double the length of the tubing.  Why you ask?…

What I learned about Draft Dispensing at NHC #1 – “Estimates aren’t always right”

Estimations for the resistance of vinyl tubing per foot are… wrong.  Practically I’ve know this for years.  Some time ago I tried to serve Northern Brewer’s Hefeweizen Recipe at traditional carbonation levels (3.6 to 4.5 volumes of CO2) using these figures.  Didn’t work.  Tom’s suggestion: Double the amount of vinyl tubing called for and trim until you get an acceptable flow rate of about 1 gallon per hour and a good pour.  Along those lines, Tom also suggested buying your tubing in 100 foot rolls.

What I learned about Draft Dispensing at NHC #2 – “Longer Shank = Less Foam”

A longer shank means… a colder faucet.  More mass inside your kegerator or keezer keeps your faucet colder and reduces foam.

What I learned about Draft Dispensing at NHC #3 – “Safety First”

Tom’s advice is… Do not place your kegerator in your basement.  A catastrophic failure could cause the tank to drain, flooding your basement with CO2.  Tom also recommended the use of a CO2 Alarm.  He said he got his at Amazon.  He, rightly, mentions that these are difficult to find and a bit on the expensive side.  Carbon Monoxide alarms abound, CO2 alarms are more rare.  In fact if you search for “CO2 Alarm”  on Amazon, the site believes you’ve mistyped and instead shows you Carbon Monoxide Alarms.  This altered search helps a bit, specifically excluding the term monoxide.  It seems some units only report CO2 levels without issuing an alarm.  Here are a couple of models that have alarms: Indoor Air Quality Meter and Supco IAQ50 Wall Mounted Indoor Air Quality Monitor.  As for me… my kegerator is in… my basement and I have a… 20 lb CO2 tank.  At this point, I’m not planning to move it.  I am, however, going to get a CO2 alarm in short order.

Pinned: Used Barrels · CO2 Manifold · New:Tower of Power · \$7:Bazooka Screen

Talk Like a Pirate Sale: 13% Off at Adventures in Homebrewing

Recent Finds:

# Cost Comparison: Kit Cost vs Individual Ingredients – A Look at Five Kits

Here’s a look at five Northern Brewer Recipe Kits with a cost comparison on buying the kit vs buying individual ingredients and some general thoughts on the subject.

First, A look at Northern Brewer’s most popular kitDead Ringer IPA

All Grain Version
The all grain kit costs \$25.45 excluding yeast and priming sugar.  This, along with the rest of the kits and ingredients mentioned here, qualifies for Northern Brewer’s Flat Rate Shipping Promo.

Piecing it out:

11-lbs. Rahr-2-Row @ \$1.29/lb – \$14.19
1-lbs. Briess Caramel 40 @ 1.79/lb – \$1.79
5.75-oz. Centennial -(you must buy 6 ounces) @ \$2.25/ou – \$11.25

Total = \$27.23

You save 7.5% by purchasing the kit

Extract Version

The extract kit costs \$40.45 excluding yeast and priming sugar.

Piecing it out:

1-lbs. Briess Caramel 40 @ 1.79/lb – \$1.79
9.15 lbs Gold malt syrup (1 x 6 lb + 1 x 3.15 lb) – \$25.98

6-oz. Centennial - @ \$2.25/ou – \$11.25

Total = \$39.61

You save .2% by purchasing individual ingredients

Next.. A look at Northern Brewer’s Kiwi Express.  This is the most recent beer that I’ve brewed.  I’ll be kegging it soon and look forward to giving it a try.
All Grain Version
The all grain kit costs \$32.45 excluding yeast and priming sugar.

Piecing it out:

11.5-lbs Malteurop American 2 row Pale (You must buy 12 lbs) – \$17.88
0.5-lbs. Briess Caramel 20 (You must buy 1 lb) – \$1.99
1-oz New Zealand Nelson Sauvin – \$3.30
2-oz New Zealand Motueka – \$5.98
4-oz New Zealand Wakatu – \$6.36

Total = \$35.81

You save 9% by purchasing the kit

Extract Version

The extract kit costs \$45.45 excluding yeast and priming sugar.

Piecing it out:

6 lbs Pilsen malt syrup – \$17.99
2 lbs Briess Pilsen DME – \$9
0.5-lbs. Briess Caramel 20 (You must buy 1 lb) – \$1.99
1-oz New Zealand Nelson Sauvin – \$3.30
2-oz New Zealand Motueka – \$5.98
4-oz New Zealand Wakatu – \$6.36

Total = \$45.21

The kit vs individual ingredients are almost identical in price, just 24 cents separates them.  You save .005% by purchasing individual ingredients.

A look at one more beer… The All Grain Version of Cascade Mountains West Coast Imperial IPA.  I have this kit slated for an upcoming brew day.  A friend of mine brewed this and it’s a great beer.  I was interested to see how this one stacked up primarily because of the copious amounts of ingredients.
The all grain kit costs \$42.24 excluding yeast and priming sugar.

Piecing it out:

10-lbs. Rahr 2 row – \$12.90
4.5-lbs. English Maris Otter (You must buy 5 lbs) – \$8.95
0.50-lbs. Briess Caramel 10 (You must buy 1 lb) – \$1.79
2-lbs. Corn Sugar – \$5
2-oz Summit – \$3.50

Total = \$46.14

You save 8.5% by purchasing the kit

General Thoughts:

With this small sample size, it appears that extract kits are about identical in price and you can save some money by going with the kits for all grain recipes… between 7.5% and 9% savings.

Beyond savings, kits can also be a way to obtain more difficult to find hops.  Some retailers will hold back popular ingredients for use in their kits.

It is a bit of legwork to do these price comparisons.  You also increase your chances of ordering incorrectly when piecing out a recipe.

An advantage to piecing together recipes is some additional control over the recipe including the ability to scale up or down the for volume or efficiency reasons.  Of course, you need to have the recipe to do this.  If a vendor is unwilling to share this information, buy the kit and the recipe is yours for a future batch.

Another ancillary benefit to piecing together… You may end up with a few odds and ends left over for a future batch.  I have bunches of odds and ends around, which makes me feels good, but in practice, I rarely go back and use stuff.  I’m sure some people do.

Of course, more savings can be realized by buying hops and grain in bulk.

Bottom Line: There are savings to be had with some kits.  Unless you want or need more control… buy the kit.  If you’re on a strict budget (or you need something to do :)… put pencil to paper at your favorite retailer and consider bulk purchases.

PinnedGrowler *50% Off BWH

# Small Batch, All Grain Stove Top Brewing + Spreadsheet

For many of us, today is a good day to… stay inside.  This small batch stove top technique works great.  It’s my go to technique when it’s too cold outside to brew…

For fun and sport, I’ve been brewing small (1-3 gallon) batches of all grain on my stove top.  It’s a simple, quick and economical way to brew all grain.  It’s been a blast!

What kind of gear is needed to accomplish this amazing feat?  A comprehensive list follows.

1.  A Bag.

That’s about it.  You kind of just need a bag.

My total investment was about \$4 for two bags.  This assumes you already have a reasonably sized kettle that you’ve used for extract and a thermometer.  My extract kettle is 6 gallons.

What is All Grain Brewing?
In a (very small) nutshell…
• Soaking malted grains at a set temp using a set amount of water.  This triggers enzymes that convert complex carbohydrates to simple, fermentable sugars.
• Separating those grains from the sugary wort.
• Rinsing to retrieve some of the additional sugar that remains on the grains.

Small Batch Brew in a Bag (BIAB) Step By Step:
1. Decide on a recipe and a batch size and gather your ingredients.  Buy your grain pre-crushed if you don’t have a mill.  More info on recipe sizing below.
2. Heat the right amount of water to the correct temperature.  How do you figure that out?  Use the spreadsheet below.
3. Put an appropriate fine mesh bag in your kettle.  Make sure the bag is large enough to hold your grain.  I’ve found with my 6 gallon kettle, doing one to three gallon batches, that a 5 gallon nylon paint strainer bag is perfect.  It’s plenty large enough to hold the grain and it’s not so large that it sits on the bottom of the kettle.  This helps to avoid scorching the bag.
4. Put your crushed grain in the bag inside of the kettle.  Mix everything well and take a temperature.  The mash should settle out around your target temperature.  If it’s a little low, add some direct heat and stir.  If it’s a little high, add some ice and stir.  Your temperature does not need to be exact.
5. Put the lid on your kettle and wait, usually 60 minutes, depending on the recipe.  Your grains are mashing.  Because there is no insulation, I usually take a temperature measurement half way through and add a bit of heat to bring it back up to the right temp.  Again, stir when you are adding heat.
6. When the mash time is up, grab the bag and lift it out of your kettle.  I give it a spin or two to close up the bag.  Let it drip for several seconds.  I also give it a few light squeezes.  Have a large bowl nearby ready to receive your bag of spent grain.  When you have the time, discard the grains and rinse out the bag.  It’s ready for another use!
7. Start boiling!

You will notice, there was no rinsing of grains.  The technique that I’ve outlined, is a no sparge method.  You’re just losing a little efficiency.  No big deal in my book.

This is a simplified version of my regular brew day spreadsheet.

(Click the graphic to enlarge)

Green cells are to fill in as necessary.  Blue cells are calculated values.  The directions section is calculated as well and puts all the numbers into sentence form.

Plug in your numbers under “Beer Info” and go.  You can adjust grain absorption rate and boil off rate, in the constants section, if you know your numbers or just leave the default values in place.

Open Office Version

How do you get an appropriately sized recipe?

1. Use a free unlimited duration Brewer’s Friend Trial Account - Here.  Brewer’s Friend allows you to easily scale recipes up and down.
2. Divide a 5 gallon ingredient kit or recipe down to whatever size you need.  Want to brew a 1.25 gallon batch?  Divide your 5 gallon recipe in quarters.  If you’re physically doing this with a recipe kit, make sure the grain is mixed up thoroughly to evenly disperse specialty grains.  You are losing a bit of accuracy in hop utilization by simply dividing a recipe.  Again… not a big deal in my book.
3. I’m coming at this from a small batch perspective, but there’s nothing saying you couldn’t do this with a 5 or 10 gallon batch.  You just need get the right sized kettle and bag.

Important Note
However you end up with ingredients and a recipe, pay special note to the “Total Mash Volume” cell in the spreadsheet.  After you plug in your numbers in the “Beer Info” section, this estimates the total volume of your mash.  This should be less than the size of your kettle!  Special thanks to the Green Bay Rackers.  The Total Mash Volume calculation is an adaptation of the excellent “Can I mash it” online calculator.

Gear

The Bag:

Thanks to tipster Todd for this!  By the way, Todd is the guy behind Grog Tag.

These are elastic top nylon paint straining bags.  You get 2 for \$3.97 with free pickup at your local Home Depot.

The elastic helps keep the bag from falling into the kettle when filled with grain.

-OR-
2 Pack 5 Gallon Nylon Strainers 11523 - \$2.50 + \$1.59 Shipping

Kettle:

If you don’t have a large enough kettle to do the batches you’re interested in, check out the kettles tag.

If you’re looking to replicate this 1-3 gallon procedure.  Consider the 6 Gallon Winware Kettle.

Winware Professional Aluminum Kettle 6 Gallon - \$40.53 Shipped

These do not sell with lids, so add one on if you’d like.

Larger Batch Sizes…
If you want room to do larger BIAB batches, full boil extract batches and all grain batches.  Consider this 10 gallon kettle and lid.  This doesn’t cost much more vs the 6 gallon size.  As far as a bag for larger batch sizes… More Beer makes a larger bag that works well for full 5 gallon batches.  Some pictures of that bag in action are in our Brewing Pliny the Elder post.

Thermometer:

If need a thermometer, I’ll point you some Top Finds:

Waterproof, Instant Read Digital Thermometer from CDN.  Check out my hands on review here

Manufactured by ThermoWorks.  Super fast response time (5-6 seconds), Dishwasher safe & Min/Max Function.

For the price, this is a great thermometer.  Waterproof, instant read, commercial quality.

Pinned

Recent Finds:

Submit a Tip - Top Finds - Tips - Start Here - Facebook - Twitter - Google+ - Pinterest
Subscribe by RSS - Subscribe by Email - Email Homebrew Finds

Brew Your Own Magazine – Nobody expects to immediately receive a magazine subscription at the time of gifting.  Do they?

American Homebrewer’s Association Membership – AHA Membership + Zymurgy Magazine + More Benefits.  This is going to have to fall under the magazine rule of thumb.

Brewer’s Friend Subscription -  Online Recipe Formulation, Brew Day Tracking and Calculators.  \$9.99 per year, \$17.99 for two years or \$99.99 for lifetime membership.

Amazon Orders – There is still time to receive many Amazon items and Prime Members receive free two day shipping on many items.  Check out Amazon’s Shipping Deadlines for more information.  Those deadlines apply to items that ship directly from Amazon.  Check the item product page to confirm before placing a time sensitive order.  As of this posting, these recent items qualify…

# Homebrewer’s and Craft Beer Lovers Gift Guide

Do you have anything to add to this list?  Email Homebrew Finds

Thermapen by ThermoWorks:

Recommended For: All grain and mini mash brewers.

The Thermapen by ThermoWorks is nearly universally lauded for it’s accuracy and speed.

I’ll jump on the bandwagon… My Thermapen is my favorite brewing thermometer!  It’s spot on accurate and it can be eerily fast.  Check out my full Hands on Review that includes accuracy and response time tests.  The Thermapen by ThermoWorks is one of our Top Finds.

As of this posting, these are discounted to \$85 each with the purchase of two.

Thermapen by ThermoWorks

Stainless Insulated Growler:

Recommended For: Any kegging homebrewer and/or craft beer lovers that live in states that allow refill of unmarked growlers.

This is an amazing growler and one of our Top Finds.  Check out my Hands on Review.

This is available in three colors.  Uncoated stainless, white and black…

Lifeline 7508 Silver Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Double Wall Barrel Style Growler – 64 oz. Capacity

Lifeline 7508WH White Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Double Wall Barrel Style Growler – 64 oz. Capacity

Lifeline 7508BK Black Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Double Wall Barrel Style Growler – 64 oz. Capacity

CDN DTQ450X:

Recommended For: Those who want a Thermapen, but don’t have the budget.  All grain and extract brewers.

Check out my full Hands on Review of this thermometer.  The CDN DTQ450X one of our Top Finds.

Spiegelau IPA Glasses:

Recommended For: Anyone who enjoys IPAs.

Check out my full Hands on Review of these glasses.

Spiegelau 2-Pack Beer Classics IPA Glass, 19-Ounce

Brooklyn BrewShop Beer Making Kits:

Recommended For: Someone who has expressed a general interest in trying to brew beer.  If they have considered giving homebrewing a try whilst walking around Bed, Bath and Beyond, give this kit a try.  The recipient will get everything they need to start brewing all grain beers at a very reasonable price.

Small batch all grain equipment kit and ingredients for Everyday IPA from Brooklyn BrewShop.

A variety of equipment and ingredient kits are available in this line.

Personal Home Brewery Kit #2 Deluxe BRKIT2 with PET Fermenter:

Recommended For: Someone you know wants to start brewing.  They have brewed with a friend or are otherwise sold on it.

There are many good equipment kits out there.  I’m recommending this one because I own it and have produced an Illustrated Step by Step Guide on brewing beer with this.

An ingredient kit from your loved ones favorite local homebrew shop:

Recommended For: People that hang out at their LHBS

Does your loved one spend time at your local Local Homebrew Shop (LHBS)?  If so, swing in and ask the shop owner for advice.  If they are spending a good bit of time there, odds are good the shop owner will have a good suggestion on an appropriate ingredient kit or piece of equipment.

PBW:

Recommended For: The person who wants socks for a gift.  If your loved one is no nonsense and practical, this one’s for you.  First… check to see if they use PBW in the first place.  If you notice a container lying around and they are a socks-for-a-gift person… bam.  Get a least the 4 lb size and the 8 lb size if your budget allows.  Avoid the 1 lb size.  That size isn’t a good value.

PBW – Powdered Brewery Wash

Craftsman Wrench Bottle Opener:

Recommended For: Any person.  This is tool quality bottle opener with a lifetime warranty.

24″ Stainless Whisk:

Recommended For: Any homebrewer that is making at least 5 gallon batches of beer.  If the homebrewer in your life doesn’t walk around with one of these on brew day (and they make at least 5 gallons of beer at a time) then this is a winner.  Check out my Hands on Review.

Update International FW-24 Stainless Steel French Whip, 24-Inch

Personalized Labels, Coasters or Signs from GrogTag:

Recommended For: Any homebrewer or craft beer lover.  Homebrewer’s should like personalized labels, coasters and signs.  Craft beer lovers would enjoy personalized metal signs and customized coasters.

www.grogtag.com – use promo code HBF to save 10%

Recommended For: Extract Brewers that like a variety of beer styles.

Adventures in Homebrewing’s Mug Club gets you one extract recipe kit per month, every other month, for one year.  Those recipe kits ship for free.  You also get a free customized pint glass with each recipe.  The cost of that subscription is \$249.99 per year.  That saves you \$20 per recipe vs buying kits separately.